logoalt Hacker News

adjejmxbdjdnyesterday at 3:24 AM3 repliesview on HN

Bootlegging is copyright theft.

Is Claude output copyrighted?

If anything, a tremendous amount of Claude’s input is copyrighted.

If there’s any bootlegging going on it’s Anthropic that’s doing the bootlegging but having mirrored the video etc sufficiently to beat copyright law.


Replies

gruezyesterday at 3:29 AM

>Bootlegging is copyright theft.

Ok, but what about those shady sites that resell Windows education keys? They're certainly a "better experience" than buying legit keys, by virtue of being significantly cheaper. You aren't even really committing copyright infringement in the process, because Microsoft gives out windows isos for free, and the seller is really selling a random 25 character string, which can hardly be copyrighted.

>If there’s any bootlegging going on it’s Anthropic that’s doing the bootlegging but having mirrored the video etc sufficiently to beat copyright law.

US courts have consistently ruled it's fair use.

show 3 replies
bandramiyesterday at 5:08 AM

The current case law in the US is that the raw output of an LLM cannot be copyrighted without further meaningful arrangement or alteration by a human author.

numpad0yesterday at 5:52 AM

I think renting out ID to let others in without telling the admin is generally unlawful in many places