logoalt Hacker News

slopinthebagyesterday at 6:11 AM2 repliesview on HN

What do you mean by "libertarian advocates cannot resolve"? Like, they have no answers at all, or you aren't personally swayed by them? Because they definitely have answers to this question...


Replies

AdieuToLogicyesterday at 6:22 AM

> What do you mean by "libertarian advocates cannot resolve"? Like, they have no answers at all, or you aren't personally swayed by them?

The latter I suppose.

I qualify my answer because what few rational responses I have seen to this question are equivocations at best and thinly veiled myopic sophistry supporting personal greed in general.

show 1 reply
preg_matchyesterday at 5:34 PM

I think the typical answer is “free market” but that answer doesn’t sway because:

1. Nobody bothers to explain why something could function as a free market and

2. Nobody bothers to resolve the plethora of domains that de-facto cannot operate as free markets.

So, in that sense, they don’t have answers. “Look over there!” is not an answer.

Free markets are actually not a given. We have to build them and build in systems so that they can operate as free markets. How that intersects with healthcare, public utilities, etc is complicated. IME libertarians are reductionist and simple, which is why many people have just taken the route of ignoring their arguments.

show 1 reply