logoalt Hacker News

sschuelleryesterday at 8:24 AM3 repliesview on HN

But why?

There are no Chinese military personnel and bases in Europe. The Chinese have not tried to take European land by force and China is also quite stable. It won't change it's mind every 4 years and negate international treaties that have been signed. I also don't recall China invading another country and/or kidnapping leaders of a foreign state in recent history. China also does not control the global reserve currency and can not unilaterally impose debilitating sanction on countries such as Cuba causing the death of thousands of innocent people because of some historical beef.

Yes, China does not have a good human rights record, they imprison a lot of political dissidence but then who are we comparing them too? The US has a 5x worse per capita prison population than China and a horrific human rights record.

What exactly bothers you so much about China that the US does not?


Replies

WarmWashyesterday at 3:21 PM

China has a single leader with absolute power.

The irony is that the US is currently getting so much flak because it's leader is trying (and failing, EOs only go so far) to become what Xi Jinpeng is to China.

So if you want to put all your eggs in Xi's basket alone, go ahead. But if he has a stroke tomorrow and thinks China would be best off making pool toys, all your eggs will be smashed in one instant.

show 1 reply
stanacyesterday at 9:51 AM

> The Chinese have not tried to take European land by force

What did US do? Are you referring to Kosovo?

For context, I am European using both US and Chinese models, not rooting for one side or the other (but prefer openness of Chinese models).

show 1 reply
theplumberyesterday at 8:41 AM

I think the Europeans have had some bad experiences with the communist system so naturally they are not very keen to any get communist influence.

Once China can twist your arm you can be sure they will. Just mention democracy to them and you will see what comes next.

show 2 replies