logoalt Hacker News

retsibsiyesterday at 3:52 PM3 repliesview on HN

There's definitely an argument for just exploiting edge cases in the rules as hard as you can, seeing how the game evolves from there, and relying on the governing body to fix it if needed. (A la https://www.sirlin.net/ptw-book/introducingthe-scrub .) Cricket saw itself unironically as "the gentlemen's game", though, so this didn't really fit the culture.


Replies

ryandrakeyesterday at 4:12 PM

> There's definitely an argument for just exploiting edge cases in the rules as hard as you can, seeing how the game evolves from there, and relying on the governing body to fix it if needed.

Sadly, a lot of people live their entire lives this way. Ignoring courtesy, norms, ethics, grace, walking right up to the very edge of the law and then smugly declaring “ha ha there is no rule saying I can’t do this!!” Like the annoying little brother who waves his hand a millimeter from your face saying “I’m not touching you! I’m not touching you!”

The fact that everything has to be written down or some people will exploit and take advantage is a human failing, not a feature.

show 1 reply
raisedbyninjasyesterday at 4:03 PM

This seems to describe automobile racing.

fwipyesterday at 4:07 PM

Really, any game that you're exploiting the rules, you should expect your opponents to get mad, and possibly your teammates and fans as well.

show 1 reply