logoalt Hacker News

dgellowyesterday at 9:40 PM5 repliesview on HN

Are those exams a contest? Like, they will only take the best N percentiles? Because if not, you’re competing only against yourself and should ignore others’ grades


Replies

ewildyesterday at 10:49 PM

It's an incredibly privileged Pov to say it isn't a contest. These kids entire futures are impacted by these scores.

show 2 replies
anigbrowltoday at 1:30 AM

Yes they are, that's what 'graded on a curve' means. It's common in the US to give students a percentile or Z-score or T-score rather than the raw score for the examination. This was a source of massive frustration to me when I first encountered because I had no way of self-reviewing my exam performance to guess which questions I might have gotten wrong.

none2585yesterday at 10:39 PM

I did not go to an Ivy League but many of my classes at an alright school were graded on a curve and so C was average, B/D was one standard deviation above/below, and A/F was two.

em-beeyesterday at 10:03 PM

if they are graded on a curve then they are competing against each other.

1270018080yesterday at 10:24 PM

> Are those exams a contest?

Yes