logoalt Hacker News

dylan604yesterday at 4:19 PM3 repliesview on HN

one wrote code while the other is used by meatbags to write code. why is this example always marched out like it means something?


Replies

zahlmanyesterday at 4:35 PM

> one wrote code while the other is used by meatbags to write code.

One is not a "meatbag" while the other is not a "meatbag". And no, outputting something on stdout that happens to function as code is not "writing" it in the sense that we actually care about here. That's conflating the metaphor we use in describing program behaviour with the actual "meatbag" activity.

> why is this example always marched out like it means something?

Because it obviously does.

LPisGoodyesterday at 4:23 PM

Almost all ways of creating programs are effectively just using tools to produce code. Compiling, transpiling, interpreting byte code, etc.

show 1 reply
khueyyesterday at 4:32 PM

Claude didn't "write" anything until a meatbag told it to.

show 1 reply