logoalt Hacker News

tmp147963today at 3:03 PM2 repliesview on HN

Having CO2 sensors is mostly useless.

In Quebec province in Canada, they added CO2 sensors in all the classes in all the schools after covid. Now what? Having data does not change anything if nothing is done.

If instead all the millions invested would have gone into adding air exchangers, now that would actually do something.

And that is assuming that CO2 levels really have an impact. From the last time I researched the subject, I found that there were few studies showing an impact.

For context, from what I remember, in submarines the CO2 levels are usually between 10 000 ppm and 20 000 ppm. Very far from 1000 or 2000 ppm.

Also, CO2 sensors are usually pretty bad. I work in HVAC and I hate calibrating them, the readings are not very consistent. Leave them alone for a few years and a good percentage will simply output bad readings.

Then you see things like a teacher leaving the windows open in winter because the sensor says 2000 ppm all the time instead of realizing the problem is the sensor. (CO2 levels should go back to atmospheric levels over the weekend for example at about 450 ppm)


Replies

shawabawa3today at 3:10 PM

I very much doubt submarines operate that high

The ISS runs at 3000-6000ppm CO2. over 7000 is dangerous

show 1 reply
Hikikomoritoday at 3:56 PM

>Having CO2 sensors is mostly useless

I got one because old apartment and bad ventilation. Was able to open a window when I felt the effect before, but now I can get an alert earlier. Since getting it I could consistently feel the effect at around 11100-1300.