logoalt Hacker News

consensus1today at 3:35 PM2 repliesview on HN

How certain is the evaporation? Obviously Hawking radiation has never been observed, but is it tied in enough to other known physics that we can be reasonably certain it exists?


Replies

rolphtoday at 9:22 PM

hawking radiation is a postulated mechanism for tempurature of a black hole.

the whole thing started with information paradox, leading to the suggestion that a black hole would have to be associated with entropy, thus would have a temperature, but required an escape hatch to allow radiation, the thought experiment came to a thought solution when particle-antiparticle pair dissociation at the event horizon was postulated.

We Knew Black Holes Have a Temperature. It Turns out They Also Have a Pressure[2021]:

https://www.universetoday.com/articles/we-knew-black-holes-h...

Black hole thermodynamics:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_thermodynamics

apitoday at 7:03 PM

It's a very strong consensus among physicists, but has not been observed. My understanding is it pops right out of the math. If it doesn't exist it means some new fundamental physics is in play, like quantum gravitational effects we don't understand at all right now.

If it doesn't exist its also has profound implications for the long term fate of the universe, since it would mean black holes never evaporate.