logoalt Hacker News

tikkabhunalast Sunday at 9:46 PM3 repliesview on HN

You can pay for services and you may use the term “buy”, but it is clear you’re receiving a service, and a service in its nature is temporary.

Buy a night in a hotel, dinner in a restaurant, haircut, shoe shine. These are all services.

Buying of digital services like games, films, and music is an evolution of buying dvds, cds or records. There is an expectation that you now own something. I can dig out my dad’s old records and play them and pass them onto my children.

If media companies want to sell a license that has an expiry date, that’s fine, but it has to be explicitly communicated. Consumers have to be well informed about what they’re purchasing.


Replies

matwoodyesterday at 2:53 PM

> I can dig out my dad’s old records and play them and pass them onto my children.

What if you lost or otherwise destroyed/damaged the record, should you still have access through some other means or be forced to buy it again?

smelendezyesterday at 4:21 AM

Yeah, I can’t actually think of any contracts besides media licenses that are fixed payment for access to a resource for an indeterminate length of time. It doesn’t make a lot of sense when you think about it.

nfw2last Sunday at 10:22 PM

Access to an online server is clearly a service, hence the word "server"

show 1 reply