logoalt Hacker News

barrkeltoday at 8:05 AM4 repliesview on HN

People are stochastic. You build reliable processes out of unreliable parts with feedback and self-correcting mechanisms. AI is not actually magically special in this regard. It has higher variance and we're still figuring out how to get all the tradeoffs right.


Replies

csomartoday at 12:56 PM

People live in very stochastic and volatile environments and they manage that in ways no LLMs currently ever can. (ie: imagine sending an LLM all the data - sensory/auditory/etc… - that a human receive)

People’s job is to partially reign in this volatile environment by creating processes with stable output.

rowanG077today at 10:14 AM

The big problem is that a person making a mistake can be taught to not make that mistake again. That's also not foolproof but at least it works a lot of the times. AI are unteachable, if you have given them a good prompt and they do something wrong 90% of the time you are shit out of luck.

That is to say I do agree that building reliable processes out of unreliable parts with feedback is the modus operandi. However AI cannot meaningfully handle feedback and learn. And that is a key unsolved problem.

show 6 replies
Topfitoday at 9:00 AM

Please. If you told a customer support rep that you are the former US president [0], they would not hand over the account straight away because you asked nicely.

These models are great tools, but putting them and people on the same level does a disservice to our species and also is simply incorrect to what we know these models to be and their capabilities/limitations.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/jun/01/meta-ai-h...

show 1 reply
gmerctoday at 9:00 AM

[dead]