alt Hacker NewsI think of Elm more as an incredibly influential research language these days.
It's very focused, there's no public roadmap or official support and the leadership (which is far as I can tell is just Evan) is uninterested in most (any?) community building or core team building.
But MAN is it nice to work in. This has resulted in several forks/spin-offs. At the recent Gleam conference, Louis Pilfold joked that every Elm user maintains their own compiler :). There are at least 6 of them (two more got announced in the last month, even as the community keeps shrinking).
So I'm glad Evan is now working towards 1.0. Maybe folks can call Elm "finished" and one of the successors can do the hard work of unifying some of the forks and growing the community.
Personally, the next time I'm looking for an Elm-like thing, I'm going to check out Gleam + Lustre. Seems to have a nice mix of maintainers that care about community and design. And it works on frontend + backend!
Replies
For whatever it's worth, I've found Gren to be a very capable successor with an active and helpful community.
I think because it's so nice, that's why people are disappointed in it's stagnation. But the stagnation is partly why it's so nice!
Yeah Elm has had a very strange arc, but I think calling it a research language is right.
There was a period where it was heavily evangelized. Many blog posts were written and talks given, and there was a lot of enthusiasm and adoption.
Then the author just kind of disappeared and the project stalled.
Which of course he had a right to do since it’s his project, but I think he should have set expectations better from the beginning.
The heavy evangelism helped spread the ideas, but also set up developers to feel blindsided and abandoned.