logoalt Hacker News

silvestrovtoday at 1:56 PM6 repliesview on HN

One of the most interesting innovations in the Ukraine war is their internal market place for drones, letting each drone group decide which drones they want to procure and use in battle.

It is not a top-down decision, production and supply as other armies use for their weapons logistics.


Replies

lopsotronictoday at 4:31 PM

You also have to ponder how it looks when you remove the Chinese supply chain for all those commodity parts. Which will almost certainly be the case if we decide to punch that dance card.

Having a boundless cornucopia of servos and radios will affect the shape of your logistics/maintenance/fabrication complex.

That's not just a "Ukraine Problem" either.

show 4 replies
tpurvestoday at 2:13 PM

this strategy worked to keep Ukraine alive, by enabling them to throw literally anything and everything they could obtain into the fight. And the system enabled rapid experimentation and evolution of what works. Also they didn't have enough of anything to equip all units equally or fully, so a market-like system of was also a way to triage short supply.

However the logistics costs of fragmentation are very real (relevant to the supply chain theme of this story). And now that Ukraine is producing the better part of 10 millions(!) of drones per year, they are shifting towards more standardized drone models to simplify logistics, achieve more economies of scale and also now to have the capacity to keep units equipped more evenly and reliably.

show 2 replies
LPisGoodtoday at 5:41 PM

The system is useful for many reasons, not the least of which that it provides an easy way to avoid war crimes (which hurt the war effort via bad PR in partner countries). They award units 10x as many points (which can be redeemed for drones, HIMARS strikes, etc) for a capture than they do for a kill.

tim-tdaytoday at 4:37 PM

Procurement innovation wins the war.

tencentshilltoday at 6:52 PM

Because it's a defensive war for their own homeland, not just a job.

homeonthemtntoday at 2:02 PM

I hadn't heard this before. Do you have a good article on it? I'd be curious to learn more

show 2 replies