logoalt Hacker News

pdantixlast Thursday at 8:15 PM2 repliesview on HN

recent gpts are horrendous for this, whereas recent claudes have a tic where they incessantly add useless comments referring to previous changes and will use multiple single-line comments instead of a standard multi-line docblock.


Replies

tyg13yesterday at 7:23 AM

The incessant need to constantly leave "the code doesn't work like <bad implementation>, it works like <good implementation>" frustrates me to no end. No amount of directions against it in project MEMORY, CLAUDE.md, or even embedded in the prompt seem to be able to stop it from doing this. I don't understand how it could have gotten into the training because I've legitimately never seen an actual person write code comments like this.

show 2 replies
galaxyLogiclast Thursday at 9:31 PM

Sounds like my code. They may have been trained on my code!