logoalt Hacker News

bcjdjsndontoday at 12:50 PM6 repliesview on HN

> until the planet burns down.

Common misconception. We won't kill the planet even if we tried to. Wed make it too hard to sustain billions of humans, sure. But they are very different things


Replies

inigyoutoday at 3:12 PM

The planet will still be here even if it burns down. After London burned down, there was still London. It was just burned down.

nonethewisertoday at 1:44 PM

This is a good distinction because its a common idea but its based on a conflation: human civilizationhealth and planet health. Planet health is hard to even think about apart from humans but the planet in no way “needs” us.

show 1 reply
NoGravitastoday at 3:35 PM

Sure, and the planet survived the Permian-Triassic extinction event. Cold comfort to 70% of the terrestrial vertebrate species at the time.

malfisttoday at 2:08 PM

You say that, but run away greenhouse gases can sterilize the entire planet, like Venus.

show 1 reply
barrenkotoday at 1:58 PM

We won't kill it, but we can try to burn it. Conflagration comes to mind.

alnwlsntoday at 2:01 PM

Like a burned out brick building, a burned down planet is still there, but still also burned down. Of course it doesn't 'disappear'

show 1 reply