alt Hacker NewsThere’s no claim being made that your rewrite cannot be better.
He has provided benchmark results which provide a dimension amongst which to measure your rewrite. If you can do better by all means post your rewrite.
Finally, these kind of projects can eventually over time become projects that are actively used. Postgres is not some entity that existed before the universe was created; it was also created by someone and then eventually adoption picked up over time.
In terms of the software industry, Postgres actually is kind of that entity. It predates the entire commercial DB (and, er software) industry and is one of the first implementations of a viable relational database server, back into the 70s.
It has a 40ish year continuous history. (Which is also why it has technical/design warts like process-per-connection that we probably wouldn't do in 2026, but that's another story.)
Even with that I remember getting funny looks 20-ish years ago when I would advocate for using it instead of MySQL.
With databases, reputation is everything.