logoalt Hacker News

sphyesterday at 1:18 PM5 repliesview on HN

Yes, there is a widespread belief in tech that 'removing friction' is a good direction to aim for. But you can have too little friction that completely ruins a product and the user experience.

In game design friction very important; remove all friction and you don't even have a game any more, you might as well show the You Win screen. My favourite metaphor for it is sex: there is no sex without friction.

What LLM have done is massively reduce the friction of intellectual effort, completely devaluing most expressions of it.


Replies

bayindirhyesterday at 2:13 PM

You can't build muscle without resistance, you can't cook ideas without friction.

Both needs heat.

show 1 reply
LogicFailsMeyesterday at 2:34 PM

Zero Player Games and Cow Clicker calling...

There really, truly, absolutely, 100% is no accounting for taste...

show 1 reply
TeriyakiBombyesterday at 7:37 PM

I don't think it inherently devalues it. But the mediocre baseline for it and how much it entices you to allow it to just spit out that mediocrity takes discipline I don't think everyone has. I've seen some lean in and keep their heads just fine. I've seen others lean in and become disillusioned.

Worst of all I've seen good engineers lean in and begin thinking uncritically and magically.

quirkotyesterday at 1:36 PM

In terms of removing friction, I think of moving a boulder. Wheels = good. Ice slide = bad

icodaryesterday at 6:11 PM

Some friction can be painful. It's not always beneficial.