logoalt Hacker News

cryo32yesterday at 3:22 PM4 repliesview on HN

Garbage -> Sedra and Smith particularly - hate it, anything which kicks you in the nuts right up front with Laplace and networks abstractions, anything from Pearson - have never seen a good one.

Good -> Razavi (Fundamentals of Microelectronics), Art of Electronics, most Jim Williams stuff (AN's and articles), Bowick RF Circuit design. They're actually useful.


Replies

SAI_Peregrinusyesterday at 3:39 PM

I find Sedra/Smith a terrible introduction, but a good reference. It's nice once you've already built an intuition for how things work to be able to go back & build up the mathematical models, but trying to understand the behavior of circuits from the math first is a bad order.

show 1 reply
xqb64yesterday at 8:13 PM

What do you think about the author's upcoming book ("The Secret Life of Circuits")[0], for someone who is just starting out with electronics?

[0]: https://nostarch.com/secret-life-of-circuits

show 1 reply
variadixyesterday at 6:20 PM

Agreed on Sedra and Smith vs Razavi. Razavi uploaded lectures to YouTube that helped me a ton at the time.

bsdertoday at 2:38 AM

> Art of Electronics

I would never recommend AoE to pretty much anybody nowadays. The problem is that AoE happily presents circuits you should almost never use right next to circuits you should almost always use with no indications distinguishing the two.