> I think the animosity to AI is more complex. There's combinations of anger about wealth disparity, a loss of trust, another of Sagan's great demotions, and this weird anticapitalist embracing of a hypercapitalist notion of Intellectual property.

I think a lot of the animosity is fear. For decades, software engineering/development/programming provided good wages,relative stability, and often satisfyingly challenging work. You saw a lot of people from secure parts of the economy being told to "learn to code," to secure their futures. Now you've got business leaders racing hard to push us into economic obsolescence or precarity (because that's where they want all labor).

It's not some bullshit about "personal identity tied up in being a hacker (broadly defined)" or liking code golf.

I think a lot of the enthusiasm of AI is from people who are too arrogant to read the writing on the wall, and it doesn't help that software engineers were paid so well for so long that many of us forgot we are laborers and confused themselves for billionaires (and adopted billionaire ideology, like libertarianism and opposition to unions).