logoalt Hacker News

deepsunlast Monday at 10:13 PM3 repliesview on HN

Too few prosecutors. Police only arrests, but the real job is done by prosecutors. However, there's a global shortage of them, and cities don't hire more. I don't know whether that's a popular job nowadays.

So without proper charges judge cannot do anything but release. Police cannot do anything but arrest.

Prosecutors are the main line of defense (defending public from criminals).


Replies

declan_robertslast Monday at 10:29 PM

I don't believe at all this is from a lack of funds. The only thing that lacks here is the desire to put criminals in prison.

MisterMoweryesterday at 2:02 AM

No, it’s not a quantity issue, it’s a quality issue.

DAs used to go after particularly egregious offenders and throw the book at them. This creates incentive effects for all the other would be criminals. It doesn’t take all that much enforcement before criminals get the idea and stop or are put in jail for decades.

Instead we have prosecutors going after all the wrong kinds of crime. Murderers are getting no cash bail while guys who cut down a tree in their yard are getting visits from the police and court summons for non-crimes.

This is intentional policy from DA offices. Pay attention next time your DA is up for reelection, they impact your quality of life far more than your representatives.

chapslast Monday at 10:22 PM

And public defenders are the main line of defense against prosecutors yet prosecution budgets are significantly higher.