logoalt Hacker News

regularfryyesterday at 3:10 PM3 repliesview on HN

The fanfare over multi-touch in phones is something I've never understood. It's flashy but phone use (certainly my phone use) is optimised for one thumb, not two fingers.


Replies

tverbeureyesterday at 7:19 PM

There's a difference between "optimized for" and "it's the only thing you need".

I could in theory get by with + and - buttons to zoom in and out of a map, but it's way more convenient to use pinch to zoom. But even for the browser, I use pinch to zoom all the time.

hyperhelloyesterday at 7:21 PM

You can do things with your hands (fingers) This gives many people an enormously satisfying feeling.

justsomehnguyyesterday at 11:10 PM

If somehow you could have the same phone but with a resistive, single-touch screen and use it just like you use it now, then you would learn what:

a resistive screens do actually need to be pressed instead of just touched, if you never get a literal sore thumb from a touch screen usage - well you don't miss anything but it's quite painful after a while and adds to a carpal tunnel syndrome

a multi-touch sensor greatly helps when you need to discern and filter out the false positives