logoalt Hacker News

sebastiennightyesterday at 5:42 PM2 repliesview on HN

This is a wild argument.

If I use the word "semantic", do you have a concept of what it means?

If so, can you please share which of your senses have shaped the world experience that inform this concept? What have you smelled, tasted, caressed, that informed this concept outside of words?

If I make up the word "polysemantic", do you need to recall a personal experience of polyamory to understand it, or could you possibly use your concept of "poly" and your concept of "semantic" to figure out this new concept?


Replies

rsoto2yesterday at 10:40 PM

Yes. When someone is teaching you language as a baby you have eyes and ears and 100 million nerve endings and constant "training" to understand language. You cannot understand the word "semantics" as a human without this crucial "training" step. My god you people will pull out the most bs metaphors to justify being in awe(and debt) to a software program.

sublinearyesterday at 6:06 PM

Yes, but are you claiming that LLMs perform more specific acts of cognition beyond organizing information?

show 2 replies