logoalt Hacker News

pton_xdtoday at 6:34 PM1 replyview on HN

> A novel is a bunch of words

> What's valuable in a novel (or a poem) is in the words.

Even if the words are a lie? Misleading? False?

I'm not even talking about LLMs. What if it's propaganda designed to influence your thinking, possibly against your own interests; are those still valuable words that you'd cherish reading?

My point is that the source matters, intent matters, and authenticity matters. To me, anyway.


Replies

brainwadtoday at 8:26 PM

Most (all?) good novels are propaganda designed to influence your thinking.

If a machine could truly provoke thoughts as well as a human author, then yeah it'd be worth reading its work, too.