logoalt Hacker News

breuleuxyesterday at 9:30 PM0 repliesview on HN

> I'm assuming also, anything like a paper with data, can also be questioned in the same way. Don't object, I've seen that done.

Unless you've seen me do it, I don't see why I can't object. What a strange thing to say.

Look. You've supported your argument with vibes and anecdotes, so I'm offering contradicting vibes and anecdotes of my own. All that means is that it's not as obvious as you thought, and it is worth digging deeper (or not, it's not that important). A paper with data would certainly make a stronger argument. And of course it can be questioned, but it cannot be questioned in the same way. That you've "seen it done" is irrelevant.