logoalt Hacker News

eudamoniacyesterday at 1:14 AM0 repliesview on HN

Here's the thing. I've been an AI denier and skeptic since the beginning. I've softened. This is my reality on the ground:

I am tech lead on a front end project that is typescript with react and everything else as bog standard as possible. In the last year the backend devs have been pressured to be full stack, so have been submitting AI PRs to my repo with Claude. The PRs mostly 'work', but invariably have major problems that wouldn't make it through a code review in the before times.

Front end JS on a CRUD app is the literal best scenario for AI. Professional senior devs are using it, and it can kind of work, but still not really.

I've given it the old college try myself recently, and it is at the same time astonishing and disappointing. Yeah it can do a lot, but there's always something wrong with it. The 'something' is not always a bug; it can be a design issue, performance issue, unused code, duplicate code, etc, thus many people don't notice the problems. But I think for those of us who prided themselves on quality, the stuff doesn't work well enough to use. For those who leaned more towards speed, they're overawed. I am concerned for my career, yes.