logoalt Hacker News

dgellowyesterday at 12:48 PM5 repliesview on HN

There is a clear difference between a local system that has access to your data, and a foreign one. You have no way to vote the foreign entity out of power, and have no say over what they are doing with your data


Replies

bigfishrunningyesterday at 12:58 PM

> have no say over what they are doing with your data

It seems like you already have no say over what they're doing with your data, and they're selling it to the US.

show 1 reply
account42yesterday at 1:13 PM

Yes there is a difference: For the average no name individual, the local authorities are a much bigger threat.

raxxorraxoryesterday at 2:00 PM

The data in the hands of officials in your jurisdiction is far more relevant than the other way around and there is little control about the data for domestic usage.

cucumber3732842yesterday at 12:56 PM

>There is a clear difference between a local system that has access to your data, and a foreign one. You have no way to vote the foreign entity out of power, and have no say over what they are doing with your data

On the flip side foreign entities mostly won't ruin your life over petty deviance or find a way to predate upon you like local ones will because the foreign institution cannot project violence into your jurisdiction cheaply and without opposition the way the local one can. If I could choose who got access to the exclusion of the other it would be the foreign power every single time.

I know this wasn't what you were getting at but it's worth looking at the other side of the coin too seeing as voting barely grants us any power over how local entities use our data.

ekianjoyesterday at 12:52 PM

in the EU you have no way to vote for things to change either

show 4 replies