logoalt Hacker News

flaunf221yesterday at 8:26 PM2 repliesview on HN

You can read online how often correctable errors happen to people with ECC and reporting.

Single digit - sometimes none - errors per year in systems with consumer amount of RAM.


Replies

inigyoutoday at 11:03 AM

Sometimes I get a few per day. I only know that because my Linux kernel configuration happens to have whatever settings enabled to get them reported in dmesg.

etbeyesterday at 10:19 PM

Systems with "consumer amounts of RAM" are often run with what you might call "consumer amounts of sysadmin knowledge" and not notice the errors.

One time I took a working workstation from my home to my parents' home to give them. When I booted it up it gave a lot of strange kernel errors which I googled and discovered were reports of ECC correction. I reseated all DIMMs and it was fine. If that gave errors a few times a year instead of thousands of times on the first boot I wouldn't have noticed.