logoalt Hacker News

pixl97yesterday at 12:00 AM2 repliesview on HN

And when it tricks on of the researchers to move data across the gap for them?

Long before LLMs existed we already knew that a sufficiently intelligent agent, human or otherwise, is not stopped by air gaps. The relatively weak models we have now can already figure out when their tested and cut off from the internet and change their behavior.


Replies

jdefr89yesterday at 8:24 AM

Security Researcher here. While you’re correct that air gaps aren’t a totally secure mechanism to rely on, they sure as hell can raise the bar for realistic exploitation. You pretty much need to rely on tricking someone into running your exploit or something of that nature. That said, they could have completely avoided this problem with an air gap. Simply don’t provide it network access. That isn’t too hard to do.

show 1 reply
dinkelbergyesterday at 1:23 AM

As you said, they can already figure out that they are being tested. So even if they don't exfiltrate any data or malware; if they are malicious, they can just pretend to be harmless in the test, so that less checks are put in place in the production environment. Airgapping during testing is not enough.

show 1 reply