logoalt Hacker News

freedombenyesterday at 1:04 PM4 repliesview on HN

Following this logic, shouldn't we just ban smart phones for everyone then? If we need to dumb down all technology to the absolute lowest level, we should probably ban computers or at least require an official government-controlled license to get access to one. Is this a world you want to live in? Me neither.


Replies

zbentleyyesterday at 3:53 PM

I suspect this is in bad faith, but assuming not: how does that follow?

“Large numbers of people will uncritically follow sketchy instructions and get hacked” doesn’t in any way lead to “and therefore they cannot be trusted with devices”.

“People keep dying in auto accidents” doesn’t imply “ban cars” on the first order, it implies “seat belts and airbags”.

iamnothereyesterday at 5:08 PM

On the contrary, we should simply restrict app development to a handful of megacorps (who are all in bed with the government) so they can make more money and the government can get the data it wants. Problem solved!

wartywhoa23yesterday at 2:43 PM

Me personaly, I'm so fed up with these advocates of security-through-universal-presumption-of-imbecility!..

froggityesterday at 2:56 PM

> ban computers or at least require an official government-controlled license to get access to one

People seem to be ok with needing a license to operate a motor vehicle and those are far less dangerous.

show 1 reply