logoalt Hacker News

mritsyesterday at 3:22 PM7 repliesview on HN

It’s so weird to see people actively try to criticize arguably the most successful person in the history of Earth.


Replies

wasfgwpyesterday at 6:22 PM

That’s some weirdly perverse attitude to have. Regardless if it’s Musk or anyone else, in general the actions of highly successful people have a disproportionally high impact on the society. So they need to be criticized as harshly as is reasonable for any misstep they take.

ajmurmannyesterday at 3:54 PM

It's because his companies have insane P/E and constantly overpromise

mhitzayesterday at 5:21 PM

Are you young and raised with the cult of personality, like so many gen Z and alpha?

Because I find your words surprising since critique is what I was raised with in the late 90s early 2000s. Offline and in the media.

At the same time your definition of criticizing is very lax, when I'm stating banal opinions and a broad observation.

Applejinxyesterday at 4:29 PM

If you framed it as 'the biggest criminal' it'd still be impressive but would read mighty different. Acquiring money and power is no way to go through life. Not at that cost.

SecretDreamsyesterday at 5:43 PM

Some of the richest people the world has ever seen seem to tick all the same boxes as the least likeable and most devoid of love and empathy.

If only some billionaires (trillionaires?) could strike a better balance between successful and human. Especially since most wealth is actually wealth transfer from the poor and from taxpayer coffers to the rich.

show 1 reply
consensus1yesterday at 5:35 PM

Envy is a hell of a drug

show 2 replies
zaikyesterday at 10:22 PM

I have achieved nothing this year, and yet I have had a lot more success than Mr. Musk in the "human lives saved" category by not gutting USAID. With reasonable estimates on the weight of this category I'm quite confident to have been more successful overall as well.