alt Hacker News> Does it show relevant snippets for each of the 9 URLs? If not, then it's as bad as Google's AI summary.
Sounds like you're saying that the LLM isn't any better than Google's LLM-created snippets. The claim was that Google has no moat against LLMs, and your evidence against this claim is Google's LLM generated content.
The discussion is about Google Search results vs LLM services (summary or otherwise).
So what I'm saying is:
Google Search Results > LLM results
And yes, that includes:
Google Search Results > Google Summary on search results page