logoalt Hacker News

don_estebanyesterday at 6:02 AM9 repliesview on HN

Now compare that to what the USA did in the same time frame. Pay special attention to people killed (either directly, or indirectly) outside of their own borders. Who should you be worried about?


Replies

minrawsyesterday at 6:51 AM

Two evils just means there are two evils. We don't have to value one more than the other.

Wrongs don't negate each other.

show 6 replies
teifereryesterday at 6:39 AM

> Who should you be worried about?

For Americans the answer is obvious since they are biased in this.

For everybody else, your question is valid.

show 5 replies
vector_spacesyesterday at 6:13 AM

For a concrete example, consider e.g. Operation Condor which displaced my own family

> Operation Condor (Spanish: Operación Cóndor; Portuguese: Operação Condor) was a campaign of political repression by the right-wing dictatorships of the Southern Cone of South America, involving intelligence operations, coups, and assassinations of left-wing sympathizers in South America. Operation Condor formally existed from 1975 to 1983. Condor was formally created in November 1975, when Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet's spy chief, Manuel Contreras, invited 50 intelligence officers from Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, and Uruguay to the Army War Academy in Santiago, Chile. The operation was backed by the United States, which financed the covert operations. France is alleged to have collaborated but has denied involvement. The operation ended with the fall of the Argentine junta in 1983.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor

isoprophlexyesterday at 6:47 AM

Both of them.

vlovich123yesterday at 6:30 AM

Whataboutism isn’t a useful game. The claim was that they don’t interfere with politics of external countries. They do.

The claim is they don’t engage in warfare when they do, just exclusively in the digital domain for now. Believing it’ll stay there is naive.

Playing the moral superiority game is uninteresting in either direction. Games of power inherently are devoid of morality.

show 4 replies
dominotwyesterday at 1:05 PM

how is this not a non sequitur in your head. genuine question.

cmpxchg8byesterday at 8:28 AM

Whataboutism is juvenile.

show 1 reply
jb1991yesterday at 8:06 AM

“China is evil.”

—- “But look at the United States! What about that?”

Is this not just whataboutism? It never adds much to the discussion.

show 1 reply