logoalt Hacker News

K0baltyesterday at 6:14 AM1 replyview on HN

So you are saying that there are people that understand the value proposition and the utility, but don’t think it’s worth it to society (myself included) but who respond to that by lying about it not being effective? I guess that makes sense. Weird, but humans, so , yeah.

I react to that by leveraging a very useful but probably poisonous to society in the long term because humans aren’t good at having things that make them lazy tooll to try to mitigate the negative effects that it will definitely have if left to its own devices. I don’t see the point in raw resistance at this juncture.


Replies

overgardyesterday at 4:58 PM

You're talking in terms of "lies", but I would say this is more "not buying the hype". I use these things every day at work and at home, I'm aware of the workflows and "how to hold it", and I just don't see the theoretical results being promised. Some things are easier. It's not null. But every time someone says "THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING!!" I want to trap them in those little "phantom zone" alternate dimension space prisons from the superman movies and launch them into space where nobody has to hear them ever again. It's ANNOYING and disingenuine. It's not a "skill issue" to push back against breathless hype from people that don't know what they're talking about.

IMO, the people spreading hype and fear are not neutral actors; if I just disagreed I wouldn't care. But I think they're causing actual harm based on a premise that isn't true. People are losing jobs. People are losing leverage in their work choices. Or if you want to be a cold capitalists, corporations are suffering after they have to rehire the workers they let go prematurely. That's why I put up resistance to it, because I think it's important right now that we don't accept the narrative being sold to us, nor the societal deal we're being offered (well, more railroaded into), both of which are bad.

show 1 reply