logoalt Hacker News

vrganjtoday at 7:35 AM7 repliesview on HN

This is happening all across Europe right now - Romania, France too.

https://www.euronews.com/business/2026/07/13/france-shuts-do...

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/hungarys-paks-nuclea...

We keep having folks here argue that nuclear, not renewables are the path to take to get rid of fossil fuels. I have strong doubts - it feels like that doesn't account for the sad realities of climate change.


Replies

cinntailetoday at 8:04 AM

People arguing for one alternative over the other are usually politically motivated. I feel like you are doing the same. Sometimes nuclear is a good fit, sometimes renewables is a good fit, sometimes fossil fuels are a good fit. Most of the time a mix is the best fit. It depends on what you are optimizing for and what is geographically, (geo)politically and economically possible. All these systems are then built using assumptions, sometimes those assumptions no longer make sense after a certain period of time and sometimes you just temporarily or permanently have to adapt to the changes in the environment. This is an unusual but expected scenario for the nuclear plants along the Danube.

show 7 replies
themaninthedarktoday at 6:15 PM

I have not seen anyone arguing only nuclear to get rid of fossil fuels, what I see is people arguing that we need nuclear to supplement renewables to remove fossil fuel and the other side saying renewables and batteries(and maybe the occasional gas peaker plant or two...) or bust.

eecctoday at 9:46 AM

It’s the second of third year in a row that this happens.

At some point it will be the new normal.

show 1 reply
Cthulhu_today at 9:48 AM

It can be, but you need water, just like for solar you need sunlight and storage and for wind power you need, well, wind. Coal and gas rely on natural resources, which can be disrupted through geopolitical tension, like Russia's gas supplies into Europe getting cut off / sanctioned.

Every power source has their tradeoffs, and I don't think anyone is denying that.

What I do think is that people are making up arguments or statements that Other People have and call them out on it.

xinaydertoday at 11:36 AM

High temperatures also severely affect solar panel efficiency.

stefan_today at 9:35 AM

This is a technical problem with technical solutions. You can just fix things, you don't need to throw out 30% of your power generation to pay billions for climate change vagueposting.

show 2 replies
flr03today at 9:35 AM

Different reasons though, France has nothing to do with water level or availability. It's for environment protection.

show 1 reply