logoalt Hacker News

Animatstoday at 7:40 AM5 repliesview on HN

Why are you assuming that the human is in charge? Needing a human to drive the AI is probably a transitional phase.


Replies

pmg101today at 7:50 AM

Whether or not it's a transitional phase, it seems reasonable to want and to build better tools for where we are now rather than where we may be in some unspecified future, wouldn't you say?

akbabutoday at 7:51 AM

We think that humans will remain in charge for quite some time. Even a superintelligence won't know what we want until we tell it. The process of communicating intent/desires etc to an AI agent is a nontrivial interface problem (which Marble is trying to get at).

mechazawatoday at 7:53 AM

Agents frequently go off on tangents, make wrong decisions, require feedback etc. Agents have never moved away from being a junior that knows everything about programming but has no idea how to properly apply it.

axodtoday at 8:22 AM

If the human isn't ultimately in charge, don't be surprised when AI decides to eliminate humanity "for the greater good" or something.

show 1 reply
reverius42today at 9:04 AM

Transition to what?