logoalt Hacker News

fragmedeyesterday at 9:40 PM2 repliesview on HN

There was one math proof that was AI generated going around Twitter and the chat transcript to generate it was basically the human prompting "keep going" until it solved it.

Tao's chat was fascinating because the questions he was asking belied expert knowledge of the subject that only a handful of people could have asked.


Replies

porphyrayesterday at 10:12 PM

Yup I linked that in my other comment but copy-pasted here for everyone's convenience:

The counterexample of the Dinitz-Garg-Goemans conjecture was basically just "keep going" and finally "enough of partial results. now finish with a complete unconditional counterexample"

https://x.com/DmitryRybin1/status/2079904005652893709

https://chatgpt.com/share/6a60b2eb-0b64-83ee-9c76-7931ca1de0...

colechristensenyesterday at 9:50 PM

Yes, we're in the low hanging fruit stage where folks can just say "here's the problem" and "keep going" until a result is found and it will work sometimes.

The low hanging fruit will run short. Ultimately mathematics is a field of subjective selections of problems and proofs as beautiful and interesting. Machines absolutely will struggle with what to study, what theorems are desirable, and when do be done with a proof.

show 2 replies