logoalt Hacker News

pinnatetoday at 3:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

Much of this is either simply not Aristotle, or a paraphrase from one of his works incorrectly attributed to another. My slop meter is pinging.

Edit:

Between the misattributions, fabricated quotes, listicle format, thin explanatory paragraphs, and use of “delve” (posted Nov 2024 - during ChatGPT’s Delve Era), this is a pretty embarrassing thing for a Liberal Arts college to post.


Replies

yunnpptoday at 6:24 PM

Thanks for delving, I hadn't picked up on the misattributions. But I'm looking to read some of those books now given the comments here.

groundzeros2015today at 4:12 PM

It’s also embarrassing to see a philosopher summarized in quotes or sayings when their real thesis is probably the opposite of what the snippet suggests,

Philosophy is not about clever observations! They are developing systems and arguments you have to actually read to understand.