logoalt Hacker News

noosphrtoday at 2:05 AM2 repliesview on HN

I've worked in energy and ran the numbers. Renewables only make sense for a pre industrial or deindustrializing society. When you need power to make shit they are useless. Which is why the industrial revolution moved from water to coal in the first place.


Replies

psolidgoldtoday at 2:36 AM

Oh you ran the numbers!? If only you had led with that.

Even China has seen a stark reduction in the percentage of electricity generated from coal plants over the past decade. Are they deindustrializing?

Everyone knows coal is a dead end. Maybe you should run the numbers again.

show 1 reply
_DeadFred_today at 3:19 AM

The above listed Washington, Idaho, Vermont, and Oregon are all industrialized societies.