logoalt Hacker News

Revanche1367today at 1:59 AM1 replyview on HN

I only use LLMs for explaining things if the subject is one I’m deeply familiar with and can independently and easily verify the facts. Doing so with new knowledge areas is very risky for obvious reasons.

For example, “explain how the code in this file works,” I am familiar with the overall codebase, I know the purpose of the file, and I can read it or write tests to verify if I suspect what it’s telling me isn’t correct. Or, if it’s really important, I can overcome my introvertedness and ask the team member who wrote it…but that’s a last resort nowadays, which I am very thankful for. In 99% of cases since at least Claude 4.2 days, Claude and Codex have been very accurate. Gemini on the other hand messes up more frequently and sometimes does weird things like try to delete files it’s not familiar with, at least the 3.6 flash model I’ve been using lately does this. But, code explanations are still good for the most part.


Replies

controlbirdtoday at 2:00 AM

100% agreed.