logoalt Hacker News

mschuster91yesterday at 3:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

> Idk licensing and regulation sounds like involving more institutional arrogance.

Well it works. Aviation for example is incredibly safe if you think about it, and mostly because the governments worldwide joined forces and introduced an amount of safety regulations everywhere that sounds insane until you remember that these rules were literally written in blood. And similarly, losing your life or getting injured on a modern ship is a pretty rare thing to happen (either as employee or passenger) if you contrast it with the situation just five decades or so ago.

> We effectively have that kind of gatekeeping now with the University degree and University recruiting pipelines (all other candidates are "external" and illegally deprioritized but it's somehow allowed).

Degree mills aren't the kind of gatekeeping I'm talking about. If you screw up, you still can go to another company and continue screwing up there, which also means there is barely any incentive to hold education institutions accountable to deliver good education. In the regulated trades however? Screw up enough and you're out for good.

> Licensing just gatekeeps it more to even more dumbass people with connections getting good roles. It should be more merit based to avoid this kind of thing.

Trades licensing is merit based.


Replies

purplemoonxyesterday at 3:39 PM

Commercial aviation involves other people's lives in real-time. I put that more like being a lifeguard or EMT.

Recreational aviation has a lot less regulation. I saw a guy with nothing but a fan and a parachute just flying around the cliffs off Hwy 1. No license or certification needed.

Shouldn't need a license to make React components, sorry.

show 1 reply
bluGillyesterday at 3:34 PM

> Trades licensing is merit based.

Only on the bottom end. People with zero merit get forced out - eventually in most cases. However a lot of people who have merit are not allowed in.

show 1 reply