logoalt Hacker News

Tiberiumyesterday at 9:06 PM9 repliesview on HN

Funny result from the web demo. I'm well aware that it's an extremely small and, well, stupid, model, but even so:

Query: HN

Result:

{ "function_calls": [ { "name": "lock_door", "arguments": { "door": "front door" } } ], "reasoning": "User wants to lock the door. No specific door mentioned, so use 'front door' as default.", "confidence": 0 }

I'd expect it to at least ignore (call no tools) for the queries that it doesn't understand. And it seems like it does do that, just not consistently.


Replies

yoavmyesterday at 9:23 PM

The website says the model is for "tool calling, device use, and structured extraction". Your example just doesn't seem to be very relevant. FWIW, it did a pretty good job for tool calling when I tried it, and I think it could be pretty nice to have this running on locally and integrate with Home Assistant.

show 2 replies
petuyesterday at 9:38 PM

"confidence": 0, so I guess you could threshold it

show 1 reply
kristjantoday at 8:04 AM

It seems to love locking doors. I was hoping this would dim the lights.

> I'm hungover

{ "function_calls": [ { "name": "lock_door", "arguments": { "door": "front door" } } ], "reasoning": "User wants to lock the door. 'hungover' implies a security door. No specific door named, so use 'front door' as default.", "confidence": 0 }

show 1 reply
jszymborskiyesterday at 9:14 PM

no, this is the appropriate response to hearing the words "HN" :P

plingbangyesterday at 11:02 PM

I've got an identical output with the prompt "do not lock the door".

hmokiguessyesterday at 9:41 PM

yeah I got the same, almost like its biased heavily towards that as the 0 ranking -- my prompt was just the word 'potato'

Schiendelmanyesterday at 9:16 PM

Was that the first message you sent it?

HenryNdubuakuyesterday at 9:48 PM

This is exactly why the confidence feature was introduced, the model knows when its wrong, we could hide that part and return a placeholder "sorry I only do function calls", would that be better or you prefer to see everything?

nc55g3gtoday at 1:12 AM

[dead]