logoalt Hacker News

bonoboTPtoday at 12:39 AM2 repliesview on HN

I'm of two minds here. The pro is that the "you could have invented this" walkthrough from first principles is more engaging than "and then so and so introduced this term in 1972 and the definition is such and such". This style is a reaction to that boring and dry teaching style and tries to push towards what eg Feynman pointed at in the Brazil critique.

The con is that you don't get to understand and see any of the history of the ideas or even the ballpark when it was discovered, you attribute it to the blog mentally and you don't know what is how new or old and can't reference it properly when talking to others.


Replies

detourdogtoday at 2:38 AM

Disconnecting idea development from it's historic development is a disservice to the audience that may want to dig deeper.

Dylan16807today at 4:05 AM

There's no reason a compelling walkthrough can't throw in historical citations, is there?

show 3 replies