logoalt Hacker News

wildzzztoday at 1:16 AM2 repliesview on HN

We've been living in the age of photoshopped photos for decades now. You can't just present a random photo as evidence without being able to back up its provenance.


Replies

sebmellentoday at 3:31 AM

As long as you know how to edit metadata, you can definitely fool minor “trust systems” like adjusters, police, etc. It’s a big gap. (For any future readers, no I have not done this and would never do it, really.)

The only solution I see is some kind of hardware-linked signature showing that the image was produced at a certain time, by a certain device. In theory, you could make this signature somewhat “provable” and anchored to a specific time by combining something like 1) the latest Bitcoin block hash, and 2) a blockchain anchor, thereby proving that the photo was taken within a certain time widow after the hash was known and before the anchor was published. But even that arrangement is highly susceptible to hardware attacks.

show 1 reply
cromkatoday at 12:40 PM

Problem is it wasn't easy. Now anyone can and my point was the volume, not the sheer fact of this being possible.