> Once you cross a certain threshold, it's luck of the draw if you're selected.
For most schools, it’s the opposite.
For folks qualified to get in, they will be selected. For folks at the marginal threshold, it’s luck of the draw.
> Clearly the entire thing is broken.
I agree with your sentiment, but for opposite reason. We need to scale down the number of people at R1 schools and develop a more robust system of technical and trade schools (imho).
The spreadsheet types have taken over the universities from the professors (it started decades ago), so I don’t think that this change will happen unless and until the current system implodes.
alt Hacker News
> Once you cross a certain threshold, it's luck of the draw if you're selected.
For most schools, it’s the opposite.
For folks qualified to get in, they will be selected. For folks at the marginal threshold, it’s luck of the draw.
> Clearly the entire thing is broken.
I agree with your sentiment, but for opposite reason. We need to scale down the number of people at R1 schools and develop a more robust system of technical and trade schools (imho).
The spreadsheet types have taken over the universities from the professors (it started decades ago), so I don’t think that this change will happen unless and until the current system implodes.