logoalt Hacker News

wewewedxfgdftoday at 12:01 PM4 repliesview on HN

Why would they write this in electron instead of something closer to the metal I thought this is the whole point of AI.


Replies

luca-ctxtoday at 4:37 PM

I made something similar using Tauri but there were visual inconsistencies between platforms thanks to webkit. At the time I remember thinking I wish I had used electron to buy cross platform parity.

And I experimented with gpui from zed, that was even harder to work with.

Of course they could chase performance, but ultimately time to market is the #1 factor right now, and coding agents still aren't good enough to just immediately realize an entire GPUI app from scratch with nothing more than a figma design. Still requires a ton of oversight.

show 1 reply
super256today at 4:34 PM

It's built on OWL, which is their own Chromium integration. It's not electron.

Seems pretty solid for Mac, but idk about Windows and Linux.

https://openai.com/index/building-chatgpt-atlas/

jampekkatoday at 4:36 PM

Because electron gets shit done? Aside the memory usage, electron/browser based applications of any complexity tend to be better and develop a lot faster.

show 1 reply
justmedeptoday at 4:36 PM

More testing you still need good engineers for every native platform if you go native. We all know that AI in the hands of incompetent people is bad.