logoalt Hacker News

moralestapiatoday at 3:46 PM3 repliesview on HN

Electric aircraft makes no economic sense, but I'd want to see them flying one day nonetheless.


Replies

toasty228today at 3:50 PM

> Electric aircraft makes no economic sense

You better start working on them now if you want them to be ready when they'll make economical sense, which might be in a not so distant future

ggreertoday at 5:00 PM

Around 15-20% of the cost of the lifetime of a jet aircraft is fuel. Electricity is much cheaper than fuel, so that would mean significantly lower ticket prices. Of course, such aircraft can only fly on routes shorter than their maximum range, so they will only compete with jets/turboprops on regional flights.

Even if the initial cost of an electric plane is higher than a combustion equivalent, the cost of the aircraft itself is only 5% of its lifetime cost. So an electric aircraft's purchase price could be twice as much and still represent a cost savings for an airline. And that's not even counting other advantages such as reduced maintenance needs for EVs.

datadrivenangeltoday at 4:04 PM

For short haul they make sense at high fuel prices.

And for medium haul they make sense if you can get beamed power working.