logoalt Hacker News

MEMORYC_RRUPTEDtoday at 10:30 AM4 repliesview on HN

It's not even code for me, but the prose it writes. For some reason, the way Opus 5 "talk" elicits frustration in a way that 4.5 to 4.8 never did. Can't put my finger on why, but I've flipped over to Codex because what it produced wasn't worth the frustration.


Replies

jbs789today at 1:47 PM

I found myself swearing at it more recently.

It was going off today about having “shipped” something and I was like no… nothing has even been committed.

And then it produced an incredibly verbose comment about hypothetical future changes. And all I could think was sure, let’s keep it short, or add a simple test that will break if that hypothetical becomes true.

Or maybe I’m just more easily annoyed recently…

show 1 reply
pjm331today at 4:25 PM

I took a month off and recently came back and was wondering if that was it but it is absolutely headache inducing in a way I don’t remember earlier models being

netniuqtoday at 11:25 AM

for me it feels very similar to the trends already apparent in 4.5-4.8, just way, way worse.

thr0wtoday at 2:58 PM

It is rage inducing.