logoalt Hacker News

inigyouyesterday at 1:10 AM4 repliesview on HN

Has it been proven that no patent troll holds a patent covering RISC-V?

Of course not because that's impossible to prove.


Replies

u1hcw9nxyesterday at 5:49 PM

If you iterate trough every concept RISC-V has, you might be able to prove it.

The RISC/MIPS concepts date back over 40 years. The base instruction set is intentionally designed with unencumbered, expired, or public-domain architectural concepts.

RICV-V microarchitectures and implementations are at much high risk of violating patents. Especially anything that is even slightly high performance. SiFive, Andes , and Alibaba’s T-Head are filing thousands of patents on microarchitectural optimizations and extensions. China's RISC-V patent-sharing alliances and other industry groups are building defensive patent cross-license around their RISC-V-related patents.

pavlovyesterday at 5:42 PM

Patents only last 20 years.

If you build your architecture on ideas that are documented to be older than twenty years, it greatly reduces the risk that a patent holder comes from nowhere: even if they did have the patent, it would have expired.

show 1 reply
wren6991yesterday at 1:12 AM

You might find this relevant: RISC-V Genealogy (2016) https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/EECS-2016-6.pdf

Or in poster form: https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/RISC-V-Instruct...

show 1 reply
fluffybucktsnekyesterday at 1:25 AM

> Of course not because that's impossible to prove.

Why?

show 1 reply