logoalt Hacker News

SubmarineClubyesterday at 8:37 PM6 repliesview on HN

> metabolic changes that make weight loss harder

Which are vastly overblown. I diet every year as part of bodybuilding, at a range of intensities and durations, and have never had issues with sudden metabolic changes that make it harder to lose weight.


Replies

kelnostoday at 11:21 AM

"This doesn't happen to me, so clearly it doesn't happen to enough other people to be a real thing."

Also consider that, as a bodybuilder, everything about you that matters to this discussion is significantly different from someone who is not a bodybuilder, which is most people.

eapressoandcatsyesterday at 11:00 PM

That’s very nice for you, but it is a phenomenon that is well documented by research: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4989512/

preg_matchyesterday at 11:13 PM

Your body naturally tries to maintain homeostasis. When you cut your food supply below what your average is, and probably has been for years, your body will fight you in every way it can.

For example, I eat too much and started eating less. I now eat normal portions instead of portions fit for 2 people. I have more than enough food and energy, and yet, I am hungry. The hunger is fake, I certainly don’t need more calories. But my body thinks it does based off of its knowledge.

dawnerdtoday at 12:34 AM

See that’s the problem. What works for you doesn’t work for others like me that have tried dieting. It’s the food noise that’s the problem and it’s a mental issue. Glp-1 has helped me a lot. The metabolic changes are kind of insane. Even doing keto which did help lose weight didn’t have this kind of effect on me.

taneqtoday at 5:16 AM

That’s nice. Many peoples’ experience differs. Congrats on it working on your computer.

Personally on the whole I’ve had no issues with controlling my weight. I’ve had a couple of isolated instances where I felt hungry all the time and started gaining weight rapidly despite my best efforts. Circumstances changed and it stopped. It sucked and I learned a new level of empathy for the people who get this all the time and not just as a one off.

krustyburgertoday at 6:50 AM

Bodybuilding, eh? That makes you vastly more likely to believe in bro-science.