logoalt Hacker News

matheusmoreiratoday at 5:05 AM2 repliesview on HN

> highly effective

Purely behavioral lifestyle interventions have the lowest long term success rates of all available treatments for obesity. It's especially unreliable if you have weight loss targets higher than 15%.

They are of course still widely recommended due to numerous benefits other than weight loss, but "highly effective" is just wrong in the context of obesity treatments.


Replies

toasty228today at 8:59 AM

This problem literally did not exist until the 80s. I don't think the human brain/body evolved much since then so surely there is another problem. The only solution is behavioural, everything else is cope.

It's the same thing for the mental issues epidemic... you can't build a completely hostile environment to human life and well being and then say "welp, I guess we need drugs to make you feel normal now", now they'll sell us the drug and the cure, and you'll be clapping and thanking them for saving you, truly amazing.

show 1 reply
tasukitoday at 7:53 AM

> Purely behavioral lifestyle interventions have the lowest long term success rates of all available treatments for obesity.

What? Surely changing one's behaviour - particularly the parts of behaviour that caused the obesity in the first place - is a sure way to stop being obese.

show 3 replies