logoalt Hacker News

theteapottoday at 5:42 AM4 repliesview on HN

> It helps to know that LLMs don’t “reason”. They predict ..

Semantics. Prediction is the training objective. The ability to reason can be, and very arguably is, an emergent property of that.


Replies

TheWrongGuytoday at 7:50 AM

By that standard, human brains don't either. Our externalizations of concepts like language or symbolic structure allow us to do so. In the parlance of our times, we built our own reasoning harnesses because our intuition lead us to do so.

jayd16today at 5:46 AM

Even if that was true, you'd have to still prove it has emerged.

show 1 reply
complex_pitoday at 7:05 AM

Maybe it looks like reasoning, and maybe that's enough for some.

slopinthebagtoday at 5:47 AM

Why would "reasoning" be an emergent property of prediction?

show 4 replies